Specifically, Rick James.
Thursday, December 22, 2005
A Holiday Sentiment
As you are relaxing and reminiscing with friends and family over the holidays and getting hammered in the spirit of the season - possibly with a Sierra Nevada Celebration Ale - why not pause to reflect on those who have passed on who had an impact in shaping our lives and our world.
Specifically, Rick James.
Specifically, Rick James.
Friday, October 28, 2005
Black Shabbos
The all-Jewish Black Sabbath tribute band.
Covering such classics as:
Iron Mensch
Meshuggah Train
War Tref
and
Electric Bar Mitzvah
Album available in stores now:
Covering such classics as:
Iron Mensch
Meshuggah Train
War Tref
and
Electric Bar Mitzvah
Album available in stores now:
Wednesday, September 14, 2005
The Moon Hoax
Jason does not believe in the moon landing. I have to be honest; this seemed a little shocking to me at first. People who claim we have never been to the moon have always seemed - to me, at least - one short, delusional step away from people who think that the Earth is flat and that Nixon was framed.
However, Jason claims to have seen a documentary on Fox that persuaded him that the whole thing was a hoax. As strange as this standpoint may seem to some people, I for one can appreciate it. I personally disbelieve everything I see on Fox, so it's not too far of a stretch for me to imagine that there are people out there who conversely believe everything they see on Fox.
And, I have to admit, after doing some research on the Web I have turned up some thought-provoking photos that have brought me to doubt the government's claim that Man has traveled to the Moon.
Consider the following pieces of official NASA photography and the suspicious features that can be found therein:
Subject #1: Evidence of Life
On the supposedly lifeless surface of the moon, signs of life can be found if you look hard enough.

Subject #2: Non-NASA Personnel
On a voyage that was purportedly only made by three highly-trained NASA astronauts, brief glimpses of other individuals can be seen. This supports theories that the whole thing was staged on a Hollywood sound stage.

Subject #3: Non-NASA Equipment
On an intra-orbital mission where all the equipment had to be flown millions of miles, there is evidence of certain pieces of equipment that could not possibly have been transported aboard the Apollo spacecraft.

Subject #4: Physically Impossible Perspective
Scenes of the moon landing are some of the most closely scrutinized pieces of photography in the history of mankind. Experts in the field have found inconsistencies in some of the shots released by NASA. In the following frame, a keen observer can calculate that the size of the Earth is incongruous with what it actually would be from a vantage point on the moon.

I hope these photos have opened your eyes just a little, as they have mine, and taught you to more closely examine claims that the establishment expects you to accept as fact.
However, Jason claims to have seen a documentary on Fox that persuaded him that the whole thing was a hoax. As strange as this standpoint may seem to some people, I for one can appreciate it. I personally disbelieve everything I see on Fox, so it's not too far of a stretch for me to imagine that there are people out there who conversely believe everything they see on Fox.
And, I have to admit, after doing some research on the Web I have turned up some thought-provoking photos that have brought me to doubt the government's claim that Man has traveled to the Moon.
Consider the following pieces of official NASA photography and the suspicious features that can be found therein:
Subject #1: Evidence of Life
On the supposedly lifeless surface of the moon, signs of life can be found if you look hard enough.
Subject #2: Non-NASA Personnel
On a voyage that was purportedly only made by three highly-trained NASA astronauts, brief glimpses of other individuals can be seen. This supports theories that the whole thing was staged on a Hollywood sound stage.
Subject #3: Non-NASA Equipment
On an intra-orbital mission where all the equipment had to be flown millions of miles, there is evidence of certain pieces of equipment that could not possibly have been transported aboard the Apollo spacecraft.
Subject #4: Physically Impossible Perspective
Scenes of the moon landing are some of the most closely scrutinized pieces of photography in the history of mankind. Experts in the field have found inconsistencies in some of the shots released by NASA. In the following frame, a keen observer can calculate that the size of the Earth is incongruous with what it actually would be from a vantage point on the moon.
I hope these photos have opened your eyes just a little, as they have mine, and taught you to more closely examine claims that the establishment expects you to accept as fact.
Tuesday, August 23, 2005
Proper Application of the Horns
Lately I have noted, with great alarm, the indiscriminate frequency with which people throw the horns in public. Traditionally the horns were only appropriate at heavy metal and - to a lesser extent - punk concerts. Today you can see people flashing the horns at hip hop shows, pansy rock bands and (shudder) country music.
In an effort to bring some dignity back to this greatly misunderstood gesture, here follows a guide to the usage of the horns in everyday situations.
Appropriate:

Inappropriate:

Appropriate:

Inappropriate:

Appropriate:

Inappropriate:

Thank you for your cooperation in this matter.
In an effort to bring some dignity back to this greatly misunderstood gesture, here follows a guide to the usage of the horns in everyday situations.
Appropriate:
Inappropriate:
Appropriate:
Inappropriate:
Appropriate:
Inappropriate:
Thank you for your cooperation in this matter.
Wednesday, July 20, 2005
Great Conversation Starter
In order to complete this project you will need:
1) A Dirty Car
You do not necessarily need to own the car in question, you just need to have physical access to it. In fact, many of you may ultimately prefer to use a car that you do not own.
2) A Finger
This should probably belong to you.
Write the following on a surface of the dirty car:

The car pictured above belongs to my friend Jon. After I took the liberty of decorating it we encountered a delightful variety of reactions:
A bunch of kids walked by with their parents. The kids read the words out loud as they passed by and said "I don't get it." Their parents, on the other hand, almost fell over laughing.
We walked out of a grocery store to find two large bikers dressed all in studded leather and their old lady (also dressed in studded leather) laughing over the car.
Biker (pointing and laughing): "That's frickin' hilarious, man."
Jon (scrambling for his keys): "Umm. Yes. Thank you."
The next day at work Jon even found a response written underneath:
"She is with me."
Sadly, the car received a long overdue washing before this brilliant rejoinder could be immortalized on film.
1) A Dirty Car
You do not necessarily need to own the car in question, you just need to have physical access to it. In fact, many of you may ultimately prefer to use a car that you do not own.
2) A Finger
This should probably belong to you.
Write the following on a surface of the dirty car:
The car pictured above belongs to my friend Jon. After I took the liberty of decorating it we encountered a delightful variety of reactions:
A bunch of kids walked by with their parents. The kids read the words out loud as they passed by and said "I don't get it." Their parents, on the other hand, almost fell over laughing.
We walked out of a grocery store to find two large bikers dressed all in studded leather and their old lady (also dressed in studded leather) laughing over the car.
Biker (pointing and laughing): "That's frickin' hilarious, man."
Jon (scrambling for his keys): "Umm. Yes. Thank you."
The next day at work Jon even found a response written underneath:
"She is with me."
Sadly, the car received a long overdue washing before this brilliant rejoinder could be immortalized on film.
Wednesday, July 13, 2005
The Loss of a Legend
The Fifth Column is deeply saddened to have to report the passing of a great freedom fighter and champion of progress: Mario's beloved Chinese fighting fish, Bebe Boi (also known as "The Red One").
Bebe was only a year old but his career - improbably - spanned decades. Like many Chinese fighting fish he was drawn to idealistic causes early in life, fighting alongside the French resistance in Nazi-occupied Europe:

Even so, he was never one to hold a grudge. Many years later he played a pivotal role in the fall of the Berlin wall and the reunification of East and West Germany:

His proudest accomplishment, however, was his return to his ancestral China where he participated in the democratic protests of Tiananmen Square:

Bebe was quietly honored today in a private ceremony, as per his instructions:
Bebe was only a year old but his career - improbably - spanned decades. Like many Chinese fighting fish he was drawn to idealistic causes early in life, fighting alongside the French resistance in Nazi-occupied Europe:
Even so, he was never one to hold a grudge. Many years later he played a pivotal role in the fall of the Berlin wall and the reunification of East and West Germany:
His proudest accomplishment, however, was his return to his ancestral China where he participated in the democratic protests of Tiananmen Square:
Bebe was quietly honored today in a private ceremony, as per his instructions:
Wednesday, June 29, 2005
The Truth About Alcohol
I came across this pamphlet at ampm last night. It has some very important things to say that I think everyone should hear.

Like many of mankind’s greatest inventions, alcohol was discovered accidentally. In the case of alcohol, it was stumbled upon by two lab workers too awkward to express their true feelings for one another.

Today, alcohol is still primarily used to facilitate the hooking-up process. However, when used irresponsibly for this purpose, alcohol may result in children or - in extreme cases - even marriage.


There Are Three Distinct Stages of Intoxication

1) Chatty
- You become smarter
- You become funnier

2) Touchy
- You lose your inhibitions
- Articles of clothing mysteriously vanish

3) Catatonic
- You pass the hell out
- Coma or death may occur
The Risks
In fact, as strange as it may sound, there are actually risks involved with alcohol use, including:
Making Poor Life Decisions
For example, dreadlocks on a white guy.

Saying Things You Don’t Really Mean

Encountering Laser Ghost Cars from the Future

Alcohol Abuse Inevitably Leads to Hangovers

This is no cause for concern, however. Simply remain in bed until the hangover symptoms subside.
Millions of Adults are Actually Nondrinkers
These people are either:

1) Lonely
or

2) Losers
We hope that these facts have increased your understanding of our old friend alcohol. If you enjoyed this pamphlet, please look into our other educational materials, including:
Aspirin: The Silent Killer

brought to you by The Ministry of Counter Propaganda
Like many of mankind’s greatest inventions, alcohol was discovered accidentally. In the case of alcohol, it was stumbled upon by two lab workers too awkward to express their true feelings for one another.
Today, alcohol is still primarily used to facilitate the hooking-up process. However, when used irresponsibly for this purpose, alcohol may result in children or - in extreme cases - even marriage.
There Are Three Distinct Stages of Intoxication
1) Chatty
- You become smarter
- You become funnier
2) Touchy
- You lose your inhibitions
- Articles of clothing mysteriously vanish
3) Catatonic
- You pass the hell out
- Coma or death may occur
The Risks
In fact, as strange as it may sound, there are actually risks involved with alcohol use, including:
Making Poor Life Decisions
For example, dreadlocks on a white guy.
Saying Things You Don’t Really Mean
Encountering Laser Ghost Cars from the Future
Alcohol Abuse Inevitably Leads to Hangovers
This is no cause for concern, however. Simply remain in bed until the hangover symptoms subside.
Millions of Adults are Actually Nondrinkers
These people are either:
1) Lonely
or
2) Losers
We hope that these facts have increased your understanding of our old friend alcohol. If you enjoyed this pamphlet, please look into our other educational materials, including:
Aspirin: The Silent Killer
brought to you by The Ministry of Counter Propaganda
Wednesday, June 01, 2005
Disturbing the Peace
Today at work a memo went around about playing music:
--------
Subject: Music within cubicles
Please do not play music through your speakers within the cubicles. If you would like to listen to music, please be respectful of your neighbors and use headphones. Others may not have the same musical tastes as you or may not be able to concentrate with the music on. Thank you in advance for your cooperation.
--------
Well, in our department we all listen to music a lot. Loud. So I felt compelled to respond with this snapshot of Mario:
--------
From: Brent Don
Subject: RE: Music within cubicles
Over. Our. Dead. Bodies.

--------
Mario, not to be outdone, contributed this photo of me:
--------
From: Mario Villavicencio
Subject: RE: Music within cubicles
MUSIC IS LIFE
--------
Subject: Music within cubicles
Please do not play music through your speakers within the cubicles. If you would like to listen to music, please be respectful of your neighbors and use headphones. Others may not have the same musical tastes as you or may not be able to concentrate with the music on. Thank you in advance for your cooperation.
--------
Well, in our department we all listen to music a lot. Loud. So I felt compelled to respond with this snapshot of Mario:
--------
From: Brent Don
Subject: RE: Music within cubicles
Over. Our. Dead. Bodies.
--------
Mario, not to be outdone, contributed this photo of me:
--------
From: Mario Villavicencio
Subject: RE: Music within cubicles
MUSIC IS LIFE
Monday, May 09, 2005
Fish Sitting: Day Ten
----------
From: Brent Don
To: Mario Villavicencio
Date: Fri, 06 May 2005
Subject: Here we go
Hey, check it out, man - Richard got a new tattoo:
From: Brent Don
To: Mario Villavicencio
Date: Fri, 06 May 2005
Subject: Here we go
Hey, check it out, man - Richard got a new tattoo:
Fish Sitting: Day Nine
----------
From: Brent Don
To: Mario Villavicencio
Date: Thu, 05 May 2005
Subject: Penultimate
Someone must have overfed the fish this week, because their water looked horrible - we had to clean it out again.
DON'T WORRY, we put them somewhere safe this time. Sheesh, we're not idiots.

In a totally unrelated photo, here's Mara and me enjoying some mysterious beverages we found sitting on the counter shortly afterwards.
From: Brent Don
To: Mario Villavicencio
Date: Thu, 05 May 2005
Subject: Penultimate
Someone must have overfed the fish this week, because their water looked horrible - we had to clean it out again.
DON'T WORRY, we put them somewhere safe this time. Sheesh, we're not idiots.
In a totally unrelated photo, here's Mara and me enjoying some mysterious beverages we found sitting on the counter shortly afterwards.
Fish Sitting: Day Eight
----------
From: Brent Don
To: Mario Villavicencio
Date: Wed, 04 May 2005
Subject: Just chillin'
From: Brent Don
To: Mario Villavicencio
Date: Wed, 04 May 2005
Subject: Just chillin'
Fish Sitting: Day Seven
----------
From: Brent Don
To: Mario Villavicencio
Date: Tue, 03 May 2005
Subject: Update
Okay. Don't worry about the fish. We got them back. But I don't really want to talk about it. All I've got to say is, if you don't absolutely, positively have to go swimming in raw sewage ... don't.
They seem okay, although the blue guy's been acting a little weird today ...

FYI: The head donated for this photo used to belong to this guy Derek in our office.
From: Brent Don
To: Mario Villavicencio
Date: Tue, 03 May 2005
Subject: Update
Okay. Don't worry about the fish. We got them back. But I don't really want to talk about it. All I've got to say is, if you don't absolutely, positively have to go swimming in raw sewage ... don't.
They seem okay, although the blue guy's been acting a little weird today ...
FYI: The head donated for this photo used to belong to this guy Derek in our office.
Fish Sitting: Day Six
----------
From: Brent Don
To: Mario Villavicencio
Date: Mon, 02 May 2005
Subject: Erm ...
Umm. Hey, man.
Uh ... I don't really know how to tell you this, but we were cleaning out the Bettas' water and ... there was a bit of a mishap:
From: Brent Don
To: Mario Villavicencio
Date: Mon, 02 May 2005
Subject: Erm ...
Umm. Hey, man.
Uh ... I don't really know how to tell you this, but we were cleaning out the Bettas' water and ... there was a bit of a mishap:
Saturday, April 30, 2005
Fish Sitting: Day Five
----------
From: Brent Don
Sent: Friday, April 29, 2005
To: Mario Villavicencio
Subject: Feliz cumpleaƱos, Thomas
'Sup, dude? It's too bad you're out this week - you missed out on Tom's birthday.

Cathy fixed up a bunch of dips and salsas and we got tacos from Milpas. They made the sauce HOT today.

I swear they're putting something new in the tacos. I don't know what it is, but they were mighty tasty.
From: Brent Don
Sent: Friday, April 29, 2005
To: Mario Villavicencio
Subject: Feliz cumpleaƱos, Thomas
'Sup, dude? It's too bad you're out this week - you missed out on Tom's birthday.
Cathy fixed up a bunch of dips and salsas and we got tacos from Milpas. They made the sauce HOT today.
I swear they're putting something new in the tacos. I don't know what it is, but they were mighty tasty.
Fish Sitting: Day Four
----------
From: Brent Don
Sent: Thursday, April 28, 2005
To: Mario Villavicencio
Subject: How's the weather up there?
Man, has it been as miserable in Carlsbad as it is down here? It took me 15 minutes to travel two blocks in traffic this morning.
It did clear up briefly for a while. It was so nice we decided to take the boys for a walk.
From: Brent Don
Sent: Thursday, April 28, 2005
To: Mario Villavicencio
Subject: How's the weather up there?
Man, has it been as miserable in Carlsbad as it is down here? It took me 15 minutes to travel two blocks in traffic this morning.
It did clear up briefly for a while. It was so nice we decided to take the boys for a walk.
Fish Sitting: Day Three
----------
From: Brent Don
To: Mario Villavicencio
Date: Wed, 27 Apr 2005
Subject: Round three
It was brought to my attention that Chinese fighting fish are actually fresh water fish and, as such, they were probably unhappy and/or dying in the salt water tank. So we brought them back upstairs.
Dane didn't seem to think they were real fighting fish at all, because we've never seen them fight. He started tapping on the glass and calling them "pansies," trying to provoke them, until finally the red one couldn't take it anymore and ... well, Dane's all right. The doctors say he should be back in tomorrow.
From: Brent Don
To: Mario Villavicencio
Date: Wed, 27 Apr 2005
Subject: Round three
It was brought to my attention that Chinese fighting fish are actually fresh water fish and, as such, they were probably unhappy and/or dying in the salt water tank. So we brought them back upstairs.
Dane didn't seem to think they were real fighting fish at all, because we've never seen them fight. He started tapping on the glass and calling them "pansies," trying to provoke them, until finally the red one couldn't take it anymore and ... well, Dane's all right. The doctors say he should be back in tomorrow.
Fish Sitting: Day Two
----------
From: Brent Don
To: Mario Villavicencio
Date: Tue, 26 Apr 2005
Subject: Day two
You were warned that there would be consequences in the event of non payment.
You may find some consolation in knowing that at least the fish are in a better place now:

FYI, this "better place" is the aquarium in our lobby.
From: Brent Don
To: Mario Villavicencio
Date: Tue, 26 Apr 2005
Subject: Day two
You were warned that there would be consequences in the event of non payment.
You may find some consolation in knowing that at least the fish are in a better place now:
FYI, this "better place" is the aquarium in our lobby.
Fish Sitting: Day One
My friend Mario from work is working out of our Carlsbad office for two weeks and has left his Chinese fighting fish behind for us to take care of. Since we figure he probably misses them, we've been sending him pictures every day to make him feel a little less home sick.
----------
From: Brent Don
To: Mario Villavicencio
Date: Mon, 25 Apr 2005
Subject: Hey, man, how's it going?
What's up, Mario? How's the Carlsbad office so far? We all miss you here. Richard's been moping around all morning.
So, hey, if you ever want to see the Bettas alive again, send us $100 in unmarked bills via office courier. If we don't receive the money by the end of the day, I'm going down to the kitchen and hitting the "fish" preset on the microwave:

Hope everything's going good up there. Say "hi" to Melinda and Jenny for me.
----------
From: Brent Don
To: Mario Villavicencio
Date: Mon, 25 Apr 2005
Subject: Hey, man, how's it going?
What's up, Mario? How's the Carlsbad office so far? We all miss you here. Richard's been moping around all morning.
So, hey, if you ever want to see the Bettas alive again, send us $100 in unmarked bills via office courier. If we don't receive the money by the end of the day, I'm going down to the kitchen and hitting the "fish" preset on the microwave:
Hope everything's going good up there. Say "hi" to Melinda and Jenny for me.
Friday, November 12, 2004
Dream of Note
Over the years, through idle conversations and comparing notes with friends and amateur mental therapists, it has been brought to my attention that I have rather unusual dreams. I like this, because I think it means that my subconscious and I get along, and also because it keeps me entertained.
On Wednesday morning my alarm went off. I reflexively slapped the snooze alarm and promptly fell back to sleep, and had the following dream, which is rather short by my standards, but then again my snooze alarm only lasts seven minutes.
I am in a fast food drive thru. The female employee is telling me "All right, here's your order: Two bags of fries. A large Coke. And a watermelon full of spaghetti."
At which point she hands me a watermelon with the top sliced off and the hollowed-out body filled with spaghetti and meatballs.
I don't think I've ever had a proper nightmare, like the kind where you wake up screaming, but I do know that I woke up laughing from this dream.
On Wednesday morning my alarm went off. I reflexively slapped the snooze alarm and promptly fell back to sleep, and had the following dream, which is rather short by my standards, but then again my snooze alarm only lasts seven minutes.
I am in a fast food drive thru. The female employee is telling me "All right, here's your order: Two bags of fries. A large Coke. And a watermelon full of spaghetti."
At which point she hands me a watermelon with the top sliced off and the hollowed-out body filled with spaghetti and meatballs.
I don't think I've ever had a proper nightmare, like the kind where you wake up screaming, but I do know that I woke up laughing from this dream.
Sunday, October 31, 2004
California and the Electoral College
I am a Californian and my vote is useless.
The Electoral College renders it useless. On December 13, all 55 of California’s electors will back the winner of the state, regardless of how close the popular vote proves to be on November 2. No matter whom I choose - if the winner wins by a little more or if the runner up loses by a little less - my vote will not influence the outcome of the presidential race. By now we all know who the winner in California will be, but because this is a non-partisan issue let’s not spoil it by naming names.
In the 2000 presidential election 5.9 million Californians voted for the candidate who won the state and 4.6 million voted for the runner up. 4.6 million Californians did not have a single voice among the state’s (then 54) electors. That is equal to the total number of votes cast in Wyoming, Alaska, North Dakota, Vermont, South Dakota, Delaware, Hawaii, Rhode Island, Montana, Idaho, New Hampshire and New Mexico combined. If a legislator were to suggest giving away the votes of 12 states they would be branded a tyrant. But that is exactly what the Electoral College does to California every presidential election.
States are free to set their own laws for allocating electoral votes and a possible solution to the winner-takes-all Electoral College already exists. Maine and Nebraska currently use a district system, in which the winner of each congressional district receives an elector’s vote and the overall winner of the state receives two electors’ votes (the votes representing the state’s senators, if you like). In practice, Maine and Nebraska have never split their electoral votes because the overall winner has always swept all two (Maine) or three (Nebraska) congressional districts. This election day Colorado voters will consider an initiative to distribute their electoral votes according to the popular vote.
Fixing the Electoral College piecemeal would only hurt California, however. Splitting California’s electoral votes while other states continue to vote as a block would cripple our influence. If California commits 26 votes to one candidate and 29 to the other, the net impact of California on the election would be only three electoral votes; the same political clout Alaska’s electors have voting as a block. This is a scenario where California only stands to lose by leading by example.
Abandoning the Electoral College entirely would betray one of the great principles of American government – namely the Great Compromise, whereby smaller states are not marginalized with representation proportionate to their smaller populations. Every state gets two senators and at least one representative regardless of their population, and every state likewise gets a minimum of three electoral votes. Ending this important tenet of the Republic would allow the more populous states to completely overshadow their diminutive neighbors in presidential elections; something even the proudest Californian wouldn’t seriously consider.
The only solution for California voters is an amendment to the US constitution that splits every state’s electoral votes. California will continue to have a major impact on the outcome and the millions of Californians who vote against the majority will finally play their part.
Ideally this amendment would follow Colorado’s proposed model and distribute electoral votes according to the popular vote in each state. For if it is unfair to ignore the minority in a state then it stands to reason it is also unfair to ignore the minority of a congressional district. Even a nationally adopted district system based on Nebraska and Maine’s model would be preferable to the current system, however; if enough states insist on this model for a constitutional amendment, perhaps another great compromise may be struck.
Of course there are other important issues being decided in this – and every - election besides the race for president, but it is the big show. Californians aren’t being encouraged to go to the polls when the most important issue on the ballot is a foregone conclusion. There has been much animated discussion over the years over whether media reports of election day results on the east coast discourages voter turnout on the west coast (where the polls close three hours later), but the fact is that Californians have known who is going to win the state ever since the party nominations. That discourages voter turnout.
I am an American and my vote is useless. Doesn’t that bother anyone besides me?
The Electoral College renders it useless. On December 13, all 55 of California’s electors will back the winner of the state, regardless of how close the popular vote proves to be on November 2. No matter whom I choose - if the winner wins by a little more or if the runner up loses by a little less - my vote will not influence the outcome of the presidential race. By now we all know who the winner in California will be, but because this is a non-partisan issue let’s not spoil it by naming names.
In the 2000 presidential election 5.9 million Californians voted for the candidate who won the state and 4.6 million voted for the runner up. 4.6 million Californians did not have a single voice among the state’s (then 54) electors. That is equal to the total number of votes cast in Wyoming, Alaska, North Dakota, Vermont, South Dakota, Delaware, Hawaii, Rhode Island, Montana, Idaho, New Hampshire and New Mexico combined. If a legislator were to suggest giving away the votes of 12 states they would be branded a tyrant. But that is exactly what the Electoral College does to California every presidential election.
States are free to set their own laws for allocating electoral votes and a possible solution to the winner-takes-all Electoral College already exists. Maine and Nebraska currently use a district system, in which the winner of each congressional district receives an elector’s vote and the overall winner of the state receives two electors’ votes (the votes representing the state’s senators, if you like). In practice, Maine and Nebraska have never split their electoral votes because the overall winner has always swept all two (Maine) or three (Nebraska) congressional districts. This election day Colorado voters will consider an initiative to distribute their electoral votes according to the popular vote.
Fixing the Electoral College piecemeal would only hurt California, however. Splitting California’s electoral votes while other states continue to vote as a block would cripple our influence. If California commits 26 votes to one candidate and 29 to the other, the net impact of California on the election would be only three electoral votes; the same political clout Alaska’s electors have voting as a block. This is a scenario where California only stands to lose by leading by example.
Abandoning the Electoral College entirely would betray one of the great principles of American government – namely the Great Compromise, whereby smaller states are not marginalized with representation proportionate to their smaller populations. Every state gets two senators and at least one representative regardless of their population, and every state likewise gets a minimum of three electoral votes. Ending this important tenet of the Republic would allow the more populous states to completely overshadow their diminutive neighbors in presidential elections; something even the proudest Californian wouldn’t seriously consider.
The only solution for California voters is an amendment to the US constitution that splits every state’s electoral votes. California will continue to have a major impact on the outcome and the millions of Californians who vote against the majority will finally play their part.
Ideally this amendment would follow Colorado’s proposed model and distribute electoral votes according to the popular vote in each state. For if it is unfair to ignore the minority in a state then it stands to reason it is also unfair to ignore the minority of a congressional district. Even a nationally adopted district system based on Nebraska and Maine’s model would be preferable to the current system, however; if enough states insist on this model for a constitutional amendment, perhaps another great compromise may be struck.
Of course there are other important issues being decided in this – and every - election besides the race for president, but it is the big show. Californians aren’t being encouraged to go to the polls when the most important issue on the ballot is a foregone conclusion. There has been much animated discussion over the years over whether media reports of election day results on the east coast discourages voter turnout on the west coast (where the polls close three hours later), but the fact is that Californians have known who is going to win the state ever since the party nominations. That discourages voter turnout.
I am an American and my vote is useless. Doesn’t that bother anyone besides me?
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)